43 states urge CFTC to abandon its proposed sports event contract rule
Officials from 43 states are pressing the CFTC to drop a proposed rule that would bring sports event contracts under federal regulation, challenging the agency's bid to assert authority over the products. Separately, attorney Daniel Wallach noted on X that Judge McMahon called the CFTC's line between a sports bet and a sports contract arbitrary. Wallach's post did not detail the ruling or the judge's reasoning. Both developments land as the agency defends its jurisdiction over event contracts in court and before lawmakers.
The 43-state letter gives the CFTC's critics a state-level coalition to cite while the agency defends its authority in court. That matters most for Kalshi, whose contracts carry roughly 60% of Robinhood's prediction-market volume. If the agency softens its sports-contract rule under this pressure, Kalshi and Robinhood lose the federal classification their products depend on.
Each would then fight state gambling claims without a unified federal defense, in venues like Arkansas and Maryland where those fights are already running. The CFTC must decide whether to spend political capital on a rule that states and some senators both oppose.
The state pushback and Judge McMahon's skepticism join a widening set of challenges to the CFTC's event-contract authority, from the DOJ-CFTC suit against Arkansas to a Fourth Circuit ruling siding with Maryland.