Split Fourth Circuit panel rules Kalshi sports contracts are bets, not swaps
A divided Fourth Circuit panel ruled against Kalshi in its appeal of a Maryland injunction on November 18, holding that the platform's sports event contracts are sports bets rather than swaps under federal derivatives law. U.S. Circuit Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented, arguing the contracts qualify as swaps. The decision affirms that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt Maryland's gambling laws and allows state gaming regulators to continue policing Kalshi's activities.
Kalshi has now lost three of four federal appellate rulings on preemption, leaving only the Third Circuit as a win. The Fourth Circuit split gives state attorneys general in Louisiana, Arkansas, Ohio, and Tennessee a tested precedent to cite against federal-registration defenses.
For Robinhood, the exposure is concrete: an estimated 60% of its prediction-market volume flows through Kalshi contracts. The ruling lands while nine Democratic senators pressure the CFTC to abandon its preemption suits entirely. If the federal defense collapses, operators must choose between funding fifty-state legal shops, geofencing state by state, or pulling sports products entirely.
The Maryland loss joins state court defeats in Ohio and Tennessee and a New York ruling blocking Novig, leaving Kalshi's preemption shield intact in only one federal circuit while parallel federal suits in Arkansas and Louisiana test whether CFTC registration can still block state gambling charges.