New York AG seeks show-cause order against Kalshi in $36bn case
New York Attorney General Letitia James asked Judge Melissa Crane on Friday, November 20, to order Kalshi to show cause why the state Supreme Court should not rule for New York. James filed the request with a remand in hand. Kalshi says the case, which it values at $22 billion, could shut its prediction-market exchange nationwide. James sued in July, calling Kalshi an unlicensed sports gambling operation that lets 18-year-olds bet despite state rules.
A show-cause order would force Kalshi to defend its entire business inside a New York state courtroom, with no federal shield left after remand. The company says the remedy James seeks would halt its exchange nationwide, not just in New York. That makes the next ruling an existential question for a platform valued at $22 billion.
Robinhood carries direct exposure, since roughly 60% of its prediction-market volume runs through Kalshi contracts. Every other state attorney general weighing action now has a live test of whether a single state court can stop a CFTC-registered exchange while appeals drag on.
The filing lands as Kalshi fights parallel state actions in the Fourth Circuit's Maryland ruling and federal preemption suits in Arkansas and Louisiana, with its founders facing a December 4 felony summons in Utah.