Federal judge remands New York's Kalshi sports-betting suit to state court
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick of the Southern District of New York sent the New York Attorney General's lawsuit against Kalshi back to state court. The suit accuses Kalshi of running an unlicensed sports betting operation. Broderick acknowledged the weighty issues animating nationwide litigation over the matter. Kalshi argues that a proposed order in the case could shut down its exchange, contending the restrictions would reach customers nationwide.
New York's case now proceeds in the forum Kalshi least wants. State court judges have already shown they will freeze trading first and hear arguments later. That is what happened in Louisiana, where a judge halted trading for more than 30 firms without notice. A New York order reaching nationwide customers would hit Kalshi's revenue far beyond one state.
Robinhood is exposed too. An estimated 60% of its prediction-market volume flows through Kalshi contracts. Kalshi must now fight a state gambling claim without the federal preemption shield it has leaned on elsewhere. Every state attorney general watching gains a template to copy.
New York joins a widening set of state venues where Kalshi must defend its sports contracts, after the Fourth Circuit sided with Maryland and a New York judge ruled against Novig.