Fourth Circuit rules Maryland can enforce against Kalshi sports contracts
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on November 18, 2026, that Maryland can enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi's sports event contracts. The decision upholds a lower court ruling and follows an earlier appellate loss for the platform. Judges Thacker and Gregory concluded the contracts are swaps, not permissible event contracts under federal commodities law. The split panel revealed significant disagreements among the judges on how federal law applies to prediction market contracts tied to sporting events.
Kalshi has now lost three of four federal appellate rulings, leaving only the Third Circuit as a win. State attorneys general in Louisiana, Arkansas, Ohio, and Tennessee gain another tested precedent to wield against the federal-registration defense. For Robinhood, the exposure is acute: an estimated 60% of its prediction-market volume flows through Kalshi contracts.
The ruling also lands while nine Democratic senators pressure the CFTC to abandon its preemption suits entirely. If the federal defense collapses, platforms must fund fifty-state legal shops alone or pull sports products entirely. The first operator that cannot lift a state halt will see competitors race to geofence rather than risk contempt or criminal exposure.